Wednesday, June 13, 2012

The real cost of food

Great post by Bittman today in the NYT about the pay structure and (lack of) benefits for restaurant workers ( find the article here:  The 20 Million).  Of all the many ways in which we don't cover the true cost of our food, this one often goes overlooked.  Especially poignant now that so many Americans eat out, far more than ever have previously.  I also can't help but think about it in light of the direction the American economy is headed:  more service oriented economy, a greater divide between the haves and have nots.  I think in some ways, these two things become a bit of a vicious cycle...one where many are stuck in jobs with no advancement, no benefits, and, unfortunately, no alternative.

Thursday, May 10, 2012

Yes, I am "Mom" enough

I have more to say on this topic and have been composing a post on breastfeeding for a few days,  but have been unable to edit it down to a manageable and coherent piece.  That being said, I am tired of feeling like the decision to breastfeed or not (or for how long or how and when and where you do it) says something about your mothering abilities or how much you love your child.

Let me be perfectly clear:  Breastfeeding does NOT make you a better mother than anyone else, and NOT doing so does not make you a worse mother.

It's not a contest.  Breastfeeding is great for your child, but if you cannot, will not, don't want to do it....that's your decision and no one else's to judge.

Despite what the cover of TIME magazine would like you to think.

Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Items of interest with a personal connection....

There's so much to report this week!

A very good friend and respected colleague of mine is on Dr. Oz today....again! This time she talks about the link between obesity and cancer. Here's a clip of what's to come: Dr. Kathleen Wolin talks about Obesity and Cancer on Dr. Oz.

The website for ChildObesity 180 has launched as well. Currently focused on three main initiatives (healthy out of school time snacks, healthier school breakfasts, and physical activity during school hours), this new Tufts project is very exciting! Check it out: ChildObesity 180: Reverse the Trend

And finally, my alma mater, Hotchkiss, gets mention in the NYT for their program that connects students to the land via farming on school property. I didn't think it was possible to love Hotchkiss more, but I absolutely do. Read more about the efforts at Hotchkiss and other New England schools:

Prep Schools Encourage Students to Learn to Farm

Perhaps Hotchkiss and the rest will start a nationwide trend!

Thursday, September 15, 2011

Finally Fall!

Happy Back to School! I love fall- for me, it's the time of year for new beginnings, new challenges, and, honestly, my birthday! It's the time of year where I feel like I get a fresh start. Which is why I'm so excited to follow my advisor, Dr. Miriam Nelson, as she tours the country visiting the Change Clubs!

What are they? US Today has a great article that talks about the Change Clubs and what tasks specific communities are tackling: Change Clubs get Americans Moving.

Want to follow Mim, Eleanor and Rebecca on their nine-week, cross-country trek? Check out the StrongWomen Tour site! I'll be peeking in every day!

Monday, January 31, 2011

Dietary Guidelines 2010

Every five years, the USDA and HHS release updated Dietary Guidelines for Americans....and today is that day.

Four Key Recommendations:
1. Balancing Calories to Manage Weight
2. Foods and Food Components to Reduce
3. Foods and Nutrients to Increase
4. Building Healthy Eating Patterns

What I liked:
- The word LIMIT is back, and specifically refers to sodium, solid fats (read saturated fats, like those found in meat products), added sugars and refined grains.
- Specific foods are emphasized (as opposed to nutrients)(and they are done so in this order): Vegetables, Fruit, Whole Grains, Fat-Free or Low-Fat Milk products, Seafood, LEAN meats, Eggs, Beans and Peas, Nuts and Seeds
- In the specific messages for consumers: Make half your plate fruits and vegetables. This particular message is very strong, easily understandable to consumers and cannot be beat. I hope this particular message gets driven home the hardest.
- Also included in the consumer handout is the message to Drink Water instead of Sugary Drinks. See comments above.

What was disappointing:
- What happened to the strong recommendation about eating a plant-based diet?
- The message on sodium is very important, but it's asking a lot. It will require industry buy in, and I'd prefer to see an equally strong message about salt (what people consume) and salty snacks and convenience foods in particular.
- The Calorie Message: Do consumers get this? I think they don't and that it's a waste of space. Consumers don't count calories. The DGs would be better served talking about specific foods and food groups, not calories and nutrients (see comments on sodium vs. salt).
- The Building Healthy Eating Patterns is similarly weak. It also references calorie intake. Not very clear for consumers.
- The further reduction in Saturated Fat intake was not adopted. I think this was a trade-off in terms of emphasis...a greater emphasis was on sodium. It makes sense, but still.
- In the executive summary and key messages for consumers, the Physical Activity Guidelines were not specifically referenced. Getting more physical activity and reducing sedentary behavior is a good message- and it was highlighted- but the specific recommendations are more clear. How much and what kind of physical activity one does matters- and this needs to be communicated, repeatedly, to consumers.

So, I look forward to seeing what happens to the MyPyramid and other consumer messages. We'll see what happens...and how other leaders in nutrition and food policy respond!

Find further information, the Executive Summary and Consumer-Specific messages here.

Saturday, November 6, 2010

A Bone to Pick with the USDA

Yesterday, I was lucky enough to hear Kathleen Merrigan, Deputy Secretary of the USDA, give the keynote speech at Friedman's Annual Symposium. You *might* recognize her as one of Time Magazine's "100 Most Important People in the World". Well, I wholeheartedly agree. (I might be biased as she was one of my favorite professors during the master's program.)

One of the questions she fielded from the audience was about what the USDA was going to do to address the issue of SOFAs in the American Diet. (SOFAs stand for solid fats and added sugars. Not to be confused with the other "sofa" issue here in the States, mainly that people won't get off them.)

What Dr. Merrigan didn't mention was the checkoff programs currently in existence here in the United States. These are quasi-governmental bodies aimed at increasing consumption of certain key commodities produced in the US. I say they are quasi-governmental because, although they are really a part of AMS (the agricultural marketing service), they are paid for by taxes on industry and the boards of the committees include private sector players.

These programs are responsible for campaigns such as the milk mustache, "Beef. It's what's for dinner." and "Pork: The Other White Meat". All of these programs encourage consumption of products high in saturated (solid) fats. (Saturated fats are those fats that are solid at room temperature and are almost exclusively found in animal products.) This is in direct opposition to government health messages, such as the Dietary Guidelines, which call for Americans to "limit" (you should read that as "avoid") saturated fat. In fact, the current recommendations to the USDA by the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee actually calls for even lower recommended intakes for saturated fat (from 10% of daily caloric intake down to 7%).

This makes this report from the NYT especially disturbing. At a time when Americans are eating way too much saturated fat from cheese products, the USDA is teaming up with industry (Dominos, Wendy's, BK) to fund ad campaigns to encourage consumption?

It's enough to make you sick.

Maybe even give you a heart attack, and I do mean that quite literally.

Thursday, November 4, 2010

Shape Up Somerville: Eat Smart, Play Hard

Shape Up Somerville is an innovative, comprehensive lifestyle intervention designed to improve dietary habits and increase physical activity. It's a program run out of the research center that I am working for, and PBS just did an excellent report on it.

Check it out! (Reshaping Somerville)

I actually took general nutrition as an undergrad from Dr. Economos...I absolutely credit her with planting the seed that eventually led me back to Tufts for a Master's in Food Policy and Applied Nutrition!

Monday, October 25, 2010

Thursday, October 7, 2010

Why Banning Soda Purchases for Food Stamp Users is Misguided

I woke up (early) this morning to the following story: A Push to Ban Soda Purchases with Food Stamps. I just about fell out of my chair, not because of the story itself, but because I had just had a practice exam session with a colleague and we had discussed something very similar.

Essentially, Mayor Bloomberg has requested that the USDA allow NYC to ban the purchase of sodas and other sugary beverages (referred to from here on as SSBs, or sugar-sweetened beverages) using Food Stamps. First, I applaud the stance that Mayor Bloomberg has taken on health and the obesity epidemic. And I agree with him that we need to get the American public to drink less SSBs (but not just those who are using Food Stamps, a program which is now actually called SNAP, which is going to be relevant to my argument). I just don't agree that restricting Food Stamp purchases this way is either the right way to do it (in terms of stigmatization) or the correct way to do it (in terms of behavior change). And here's why...

First, how does Food Stamps, formally known now as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program work? Food Stamps is a nutrition program that is a means-test targeted program, meaning your eligibility to receive benefits is based on your means (your income plus other assets). It's actually got another layer of targeting built in, in that you have to be interested enough in receiving the benefits (need them enough) that taking the time to apply and submit proof of income and assets is worth it. Once you qualify to receive benefits (the main test is having a gross income at 130% of the poverty line or less), then your benefit is calculated.

Here's where the "Supplemental" aspect of SNAP/Food Stamps comes in. Food Stamps are designed to be supplemental to your food budget. The underlying assumption is that, assuming you have income, you are putting some of that income towards food purchases. The benefit formula is as follows:

Benefit= Maximum Benefit- (0.3 times your income level)

Therefore, as your income goes down, your benefits will go up, and at a level of zero income, you will receive the maximum benefit. The current maximum benefit for a family of four is $668 per month. At levels of income above zero, it is assumed that 1/3 of your income will be spent on food.

This is a crucial point, as there are really two main buckets of people who receive Food Stamps benefits in terms of how the program affects their spending: Constrained and Unconstrained. Unconstrained individuals, because they are spending some of their income on food in addition to the benefits of SNAP, are not changing their spending habits- meaning that they are not spending more than they would like on food, and that Food Stamps is not increasing their purchasing of food to a level greater than they would prefer. In this case, Food Stamps acts as an income transfer: the cash that they would have already preferred to spend on food can now be freed up in their budgets to be spent on other needs. It is like giving these recipients a raise- their budget is increased, and there are no restrictions on their spending (aside from the fact that some things are banned under food stamps: non-food like liquor, and some prepared foods). The key point here is that they are spending more on food than their Food Stamp benefit alone.

Constrained individuals on the other hand are forced to buy food that they wouldn't otherwise buy. This indicates that they have needs greater than food (medical care, housing) but the government has essentially chosen for them that they will spend this benefit on food. It's not an income transfer in this case. Even at the same level of income as someone else, this group has different preferences (higher priorities than food spending) but are forced to spend Food Stamp dollars on food. This group would rather have cash that could be spent on their higher priority items.

The point I am trying to make here is that, for unconstrained individuals, banning the purchases of SSBs using Food Stamp dollars will not have the intended effect. If a given recipient prefers to purchase SSBs, it's simply a matter of shifting their food budget so that their own dollars are spent on SSBs and Food Stamp dollars are spent on something else. This group can still buy Sugar-Sweetened Beverages at the same rate previously, given how cheap SSBs are relative to other foods, particularly nutritious foods, in the diet. Only those very constrained individuals would have their purchases changed by this policy.

This is my first problem with this policy: it won't meaningfully change behavior among the targeted population.

My second issue is that it stigmatizes Food Stamp recipients. It restricts their choices, and in so doing, feels punitive. Food Stamp recipients are not the only Americans who are drinking far too many SSBs. I feel this policy is a lot of noise and attention for one that won't work in the way intended, and that time, money and effort could be better spent on policies that have a more effective design.

If we REALLY want to change the food choices that Americans generally, and Food Stamp recipients specifically, make, then I propose that we make fruits and vegetables cheaper. It's non-punitive. It's got potential to change behavior. One of the complaints that is often heard from Food Stamp recipients is that they would like to buy healthier choices, but that fruits and vegetables (and other non-processed foods) are so much more expensive. I could devote a hundred pages to how this happened (Thank you, Earl Butz), but the bottom line is that people's purchasing decisions are based on the relative costs of different foods, and if we make fruits and vegetables competitive with the reconstituted soy/corn blend junk that it competes with (re: pretty much all processed foods, including SSBs), we just might have the START to a solution. (By no means do I think this will be enough to fix the obesity epidemic in this country.)

Food Stamps, like all policy interventions, is not a perfect solution, but it is a rather elegant one. Like all policies, it's a compromise. It's designed to not distort the markets (by increasing food demand or imposing different consumption choices on the recipients), but at the same time allow the government to put a priority on food spending for low income families. From a free-market perspective, giving cash benefits would be the ideal market solution, but for obvious reasons, this is not politically very popular. Food Stamps tried to bridge this gap, and while it has its flaws, it does the best it can.

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Birthday Post

I can't come up with an adequate introduction to this video from the TED conference. Just go watch and see for yourself!

Wednesday, September 22, 2010

A lot of talk about food in the NYT today

Check it out....

An editorial on antibiotic use in livestock.

The first paragraph of Thomas Friedman's op-ed highlights the way we're viewed by other countries.

More updates on the egg recall.

And more on the debate between sugar and HFCS (bottom line: no evidence they're significantly different...sugar is sugar and we need to eat A LOT less of it).

It's nice to see food politics taking center stage.

Sunday, September 19, 2010

If PopTarts didn't exist.....

what would you eat instead? That's the question that a brand manager for PopTarts claims that most consumers struggle to answer.

Let me help you out with this one: fruit and granola. Or some oatmeal with fruit? Or how about whole wheat toast with some delicious jam even?

Check out the report on CNN.

I'm off to go bemoan the state of the American diet.

My report on the recs for the 2010 DGs is coming. There are some interesting updates....

Wednesday, June 16, 2010

New Dietary Guidelines Advisory Report Released

The US Dietary Guidelines Advisory Report has been released!

....and everyone has something to say about it:
The LA Times
US Food Policy (Parke Wilde's Blog)
Food Politics (Marion Nestle'sBlog)

Even Gawker has a post.

I'm still digging through it and will post my take on it shortly.

Saturday, May 1, 2010

Compelling Arguement for Nationwide Salt Reduction Plan

Salt has been in the news an awful lot lately, and many companies are moving to reduce levels in processed foods. Here's why this makes sense from a public health standpoint, as written by Dr. Katleen Wolin at the Siteman Cancer Center at Washington University's School of Medicine:

Why is reducing Salt in Our Food Important?

Not THAT again

Food companies love, and I mean LOVE, to trot out the old "It's not us, it's you" argument about obesity. It's not our delicious, salty, high fat, high sugar, tasty snacks and sodas that are making you fat...it's that you are not exercising enough! Pepsico's Indra Nooyi is just the latest in a long line of companies making some version of this claim. The Wall Street Journal's health blog has a great piece on exactly why the math on this doesn't work.

Food companies don't want to admit that the hard sell they are giving us every day to buy their snack foods are part of the problem.

I recently made a similar point in one of my take-home finals (the books I referenced are listed below):

§ All that time we’re saving by eating more convenient processed foods? We’re not using it to exercise. The modern world has done an amazing job of making our lives easier. In fact, maybe it has made it too easy. A lot of these books make a strong case for unprocessed, home cooked whole foods- all foods that, by nature, don’t carry health claims. I strongly support this stance. And yet, we haven’t found the right balance between convenience and health. As big box supermarkets open in parts of the world primarily dependent on open air markets, there is a strong desire to press pause and prevent this occurrence. However, as Dr. Popkin implies, denying these folks the ability to shop in a convenient, climate controlled environment is denying them an improvement in standard of living, as well as ensuring population weight gain. The advent of processed foods, prepared foods and takeaway meals was both a reaction to more women in the workforce and a necessary factor for it. This, coupled with great strides forward in technology, has greatly increased our standard of living in the United States. However, as technology enriches our lives, our backsides widen. We’ve been fortunate to live in a world where technology has made our lives easier, but we’ve neglected the other side of the energy equation: expenditure. A number of the books I read pointed out the need for a greater emphasis on physical activity and exercise in our daily lives. Now that we don’t have to work so hard to survive, we will have to find ways to build meaningful energy expenditure back into our routines. It’s worth nothing this point because big food often takes the stance of supporting physical activity initiatives and promotes physical activity as the way to dig the country out of the obesity crisis (Brownell, Nestle and Popkin all note this big food tactic). In this way, physical activity has become another health claim by big food: it’s not us, it’s you. You just need to exercise!


Books referenced: Barry Popkin's "The World is Fat", David Kessler's "The End of Overeating", Michael Pollan's "The Omnivore's Dilemma", Kelly Brownell's "Food Fight" and Marion Nestle's "Food Politics"


Interesting quote in the most recent New Yorker

In "The Talk of the Town" section of this week's New Yorker, there was a bit about different groups of Europeans stranded in the States due to the volcano eruption in Iceland. One such group was composed of Belgian college students. One of them, Jolien Demanet, said they were all missing vegetables, having subsisted on "burgers and paninis". She said, "If you want to eat a normal meal with vegetables here, you have to spend money".

Well, that just about sums it up. Junky food-like substances? Cheap. Actual vegetables? Not so much.

Thursday, April 22, 2010

Introducing Sick Delicious

I have two people whom I call regularly on to mitigate kitchen disasters, often as they are occurring. These people are Kate and Rachel Hull (have to distinguish her from my other best friend from high school, Rachel Phillips...yep, a pair of Rachels and they're awesome). This does mean I am often borderline hyperventilating and covered in flour at the time of the call, like the time Rachel helped me get the consistency for my gnocchi dough right by walking me through it, long-distance. Despite the fact that she could only hear my best-guess description of what was going on, the husband and I ate gnocchi that night. And now, this culinary goddess (well, she's a goddess of all things to me!) has her own blog:

Sick Delicious


She's an amazing cook. I love eating at her house. In fact, here are the beautiful desserts she made me for my bachelorette party. Yep, she REALLY loves me.


If you want to seriously improve your life by eating the best food ever, I suggest you get on over to Sick Delicious.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Dr. Miriam Nelson talks about women's fitness in USAToday

I'm a big (read: HUGE) fan of Mim Nelson and this article from USAToday discusses the importance of physical activity and counting calories (have to do both to lose weight, and both are important in weight gain prevention).

Read it here: Women: Walk your way to life-long fitness

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Ready to take control of your health?

Want to take a proactive approach to your health? Check out yourdiseaserisk.com- an excellent online assessment tools with steps you can take to reduce your risk for various cancers, osteoporosis, heart disease, and stroke.

This was developed in part by a good friend of mine, Dr. Kathleen Wolin. She's a rock star!

Tuesday, March 16, 2010